Log in

The bid/no-bid decision: seven factors and a matrix you can copy

A bid/no-bid decision is your firm’s call, made before anyone writes a page, on whether to answer a solicitation: bid as the prime, bid as a subcontractor, or pass. Make it within two or three days of the notice, from the notice and its files. Score the bid on seven factors against a threshold you set in advance, and write down who decided and why, so the next similar bid takes minutes.

What a bid/no-bid decision is#

A bid/no-bid decision (also called go/no-go) is the moment your firm commits proposal hours to a solicitation, such as an RFP or an invitation to bid, or walks away from it. A full proposal for a public buyer can take a week or more of your best people, and a firm that answers every notice in its feed spends those hours on bids it was never going to win.

“No bid” has two meanings, and search results mix them up:

  • Your no-bid. You read the notice and choose not to respond. Some buyers put a “statement of no bid” form in the solicitation, and returning it keeps your name on their list for the next one.
  • A no-bid contract. A public buyer awards a contract without competition, to one source. Federal rules cover it under “other than full and open competition” (FAR Subpart 6.3) and allow it only in listed cases, such as when only one responsible source can do the work.

This article is about the first.

When to decide, and what to read first#

Decide within two or three days of the notice, and no later than the deadline for questions. Questions are the last point where you can change the scope cheaply, and a firm that decides after them has already lost a week.

Read these parts of the notice and its files before you decide anything:

  • What the contractor must do. The scope of work or the “shall” sentences. Read them word for word, not the summary on the bid feed.
  • The dates. The due date, the last day for questions, the day answers come out, and any meeting before the bid. Check whether the meeting is mandatory: if it is, missing it disqualifies you.
  • How the bid is sent. A portal, an email or a sealed envelope, the format, the page limit, the number of copies.
  • How the bid is judged. The criteria and their weights, or “lowest responsive, responsible bidder”. A best-value bid and a low-price bid need different decisions.
  • The money and the term. The budget or estimate if the files name one, the term and its renewals, the kind of price (fixed, unit rates, time and materials).

The seven factors#

Each factor is a question you answer with a fact you can check:

  1. Scope fit. Which sentence of the scope do you deliver today, and what share of the contract is it?
  2. Capacity. Who would do the work, from the start date in the notice, and what are they doing that week?
  3. Past work. Which finished contracts would you list as references, and do they match the size and the kind of buyer?
  4. Risk and terms. Which clauses would you refuse in a private contract: liquidated damages, liability, payment timing, termination?
  5. Competition. Who holds the contract now, and did you talk to the buyer before the notice came out?
  6. Cost to bid. Hours to write and price the proposal, times your rate, plus travel and bonds. Compare it with the margin of the first year.
  7. Fit with your plan. Does this buyer, region or contract open work you want in the next two years?

Deal-breakers before you score#

Some bids fail before any matrix. Check these first, and stop at the first “no”:

  • Registration where the buyer buys. A public buyer takes a bid only from a vendor registered where it buys: SAM.gov for federal money, its own portal for a state, a county or a city. A registration can take weeks to clear.
  • A set-aside status. A bid set aside for small, minority-owned, woman-owned or veteran-owned firms takes only a company that holds the status.
  • Insurance and papers that run out. Most bids ask for proof of insurance with the limits they name. A certificate that ends before the due date, or limits below the ones named, needs fixing before you spend an hour on the proposal.
  • A mandatory meeting or site visit you can’t attend.
  • A bond you can’t get. Construction and some service bids ask for a bid bond or a performance bond. Ask your surety before you score.

When more notices arrive each week than you have people to read them, check the scope sentence and this list on each one first, and score only the ones that pass.

A bid/no-bid matrix you can copy#

Score each factor 1, 3 or 5 against the answer that fits, multiply by its weight, and add up. The weights below add up to 100, so the top score is 500. The weights, the 1/3/5 scale and the threshold are a worked example, not a rule: change them to match how your firm wins.

WhatWeight135
Scope fit20Our work is a small part of the contractOur work is about half of itOur work is the main part of what the buyer buys
Capacity15Nobody free on the start dateFree if we move one projectNamed people free from day one
Past work15No similar contractSimilar work, smaller or privateTwo or more similar public contracts with references
Risk and terms15Penalties, uncapped liability, slow pay we can't carryOne term we would need to raise in questionsTerms we have signed before
Competition15Strong incumbent, scope written around themOpen field, we don't know the buyerWe know the buyer, or the incumbent is leaving
Cost to bid10More than half the first-year marginA tenth to half of that marginUnder a tenth of that margin
Fit with our plan10A buyer or region we don't wantNeutralA buyer, region or contract we want on our record

In this example, bid at 350 or more. Between 280 and 349, the owner decides in a 15-minute call with the person who read the files. Below 280, no bid. A county help-desk contract scores 5 on scope (100), 3 on capacity (45), 5 on past work (75), 3 on terms (45), 1 on competition (15), 5 on cost to bid (50) and 3 on fit (30): 360, so you bid. A threshold set before you read a notice stops a good-looking bid from talking you into it.

On a construction bid or tender, read two factors wider. Capacity is your crews and equipment from the start date, and the bonding capacity left after the jobs you already hold. Cost to bid is the takeoff and the sub quotes your estimate needs, so make the call before the takeoff starts. If, by the due date, no sub will quote a trade you don’t do yourself, stop there, as with the deal-breakers above: without that price you have no estimate to send.

Bid, bid as a subcontractor, or no bid#

Read the score against the bands of your matrix (350 and 280 in the example above):

  • 350 or more: bid as the prime, when your work is the main part of what the buyer buys.
  • 280 to 349: the owner’s call, made on the lowest factor. Take the factor with the lowest score and ask whether one question to the buyer, sent before the question deadline, could raise it. If a question can, bid and send it, and a “no” in the buyer’s answers ends the bid. If no question can, it is a no bid, with the reason written down.
  • Below 280, or a failed deal-breaker: no bid. Write down why.
  • Bid as a subcontractor when your work is a small part of a larger contract. Score your part alone on the same bands. If it clears, find the likely primes on the attendee list of the pre-bid meeting or on the buyer’s list of plan holders, and offer your part before they price the bid.

Take the county help-desk contract from the matrix above, now with uncapped liability in its terms. Terms drop to 1 and the score to 330. Competition sits at 1 too, and no question changes who holds the contract now. Terms can move: ask whether the county will cap liability at the contract value. A yes puts terms back at 3 and the score back at 360, so you bid. A no gives you the no-bid line: “uncapped liability, county won’t cap it”.

Record the no-bid and its reason#

Write one line for each no-bid: the bid, the buyer, the date, who decided, and the reason in one sentence, such as “scope is 80% hardware, we sell support” or “insurance limit of $5 million, ours is $2 million”. Add what would change the answer.

Next quarter, the same county posts the same kind of work. With the line, the bid manager reads the old reason in a minute and knows whether anything changed. Without it, someone reads 60 pages again. Over a year, your no-bid reasons show the work you keep turning away, which tells you what to add to your registrations, your insurance or your team.

Keep the yes answers the same way: who decided, on what score. When you lose, the line tells you whether the score was wrong or the bid was.

The bid/no-bid decision in Tommos#

Tommo Bids, part of the Tommos (tommos.ai) CRM, reads the notice of each new bid and the files of each one that fits, so the person who decides starts from the “shall” sentence and the due date instead of 60 pages.

  1. 1

    Set up once

    In “Settings”, “Bids”, connect your own HigherGov saved search at its level, Federal or State and Local, and write two short texts: the work you sell and the work you turn away. Keep your registrations and insurance in the “Bids credentials” folder.

  2. 2

    Once a day

    Tommo Bids reads the new bids of your search and sorts each one Ours or Not ours, with one sentence why.

  3. 3

    One card per Ours bid

    Tommo Bids waits until it has read the bid’s files, or for one day. Then a card asks “Bid on [the bid’s name]?” and quotes what the contractor must do, word for word, with the file’s name. “Bid details” holds the due date, the term and the papers missing from your “Bids credentials” folder. Tommo Bids’ own opinion sits under “Why”, and nothing outside “Why” is an opinion. It does not guess a fact: a missing one reads “not in the CRM”. The card also says when a document the bid asks for ends before the due date.

  4. 4

    Your answer

    The card marks no answer. A person presses “Bid”, “Bid as a subcontractor” or “No bid”. “No bid” asks why and keeps your name and reason, the same no-bid line as above, and Tommo Bids reads that reason when it sorts similar bids. If you change your mind, “Restore the deal” brings the bid back from Not ours.

Tommo Bids for SLED contractors follows one school-district bid from the daily read to the owner’s answer. Book a demo on that page.

Questions about the bid/no-bid decision#

Who should make the bid/no-bid decision?
One person with authority over the hours, usually the owner or the head of the business unit, on the advice of the person who read the files. A committee slows it down. Write the name next to the answer.
What does no bid mean?
Two things. A vendor's no bid is its choice not to respond to a solicitation. A no-bid contract is a public contract awarded without competition, which federal rules allow only in listed cases, such as one responsible source.
Is go/no-go the same as bid/no-bid?
In proposal work, yes: both name the decision to pursue a solicitation or walk away. Some firms run two gates: a go/no-go when they first hear of an opportunity, and a bid/no-bid once the full solicitation and its files are out.
How do we know our bid/no-bid threshold works?
Track your win rate. Divide the contracts you won by the bids you submitted, by kind of buyer and by kind of work, for the last 12 months. If the bids that cleared your threshold win more often than the ones the owner pushed through from the middle band, the threshold is doing its job.
When should we bid as a subcontractor?
When your work is a small part of what the buyer buys. The prime carries the registration, the bond and the full scope, and you price your part.

Decide each bid that fits from one card

Your next bid/no-bid starts from one card: what the contractor must do, the due date and the papers missing from your Bids credentials folder, with Tommo Bids' reason under Why. Book a demo of Tommo Bids: pick a time on the calendar. If none fits, leave your email in the form, and we'll write back to set the call.

Book a demo

Rather see it first?

Ask through our form, and the answer comes from us.